ER Nurses React to The Final Days of the Lindsay Clancy Trial | The ER Edit Ep. 26

Recorded as the Lindsay Clancy jury began deliberating, we pick up where part one left off and break down the final stretch of the trial, from the defense witnesses and postpartum psychosis testimony to the prosecution rebuttal and closing arguments. We get into Dr. Paul Zeizel, Dr. Phillip Resnick, Dr. Avram Mack, Dr. Kirk Heilbrun, Dr. Gregory Saathoff, the hospital chaplain testimony, the claimed command voice, and the question the jury actually has to answer: whether the Commonwealth proved Lindsay Clancy was criminally responsible beyond a reasonable doubt. This case left us with more questions than we expected. We talk through the digital timeline, the 5:24 p.m. work email, questions surrounding the residue found in the bedroom glass and what testing was or was not done, the investigation itself, expert disagreements over psychosis versus intrusive thoughts, and the enormous responsibility now sitting with the jury. We also separate what was actually presented in court from the theories taking off online and look at why postpartum psychosis, mental illness, and legal lack of criminal responsibility are not the same thing. LISTEN, WATCH, FOLLOW, AND SEND US YOUR STORIES https://theeredit.com Find The ER Edit episodes, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, The Whisper Line, host links, and business contact in one place. Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4Ab8DoF... Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast... YouTube:    / @theeredit   Instagram: @theERedit_ TikTok: @theERedit Business inquiries: theeredit@gmail.com The views and opinions expressed in this episode are those of Caitlin Armstrong and Karlie Tooley and do not represent the views, policies, or positions of their current or former employers, hospitals, healthcare organizations, or any affiliated institutions. This podcast is for entertainment and general discussion purposes only and should not be considered medical advice. 00:00 The Jury Has the Lindsay Clancy Case 01:12 Day 14 and the Commonwealth Rests 05:25 The Defense Begins 10:18 Susan Clancy and the Mental Health Timeline 12:10 Defense Experts on Mental Illness and Psychosis 16:58 Dr. Paul Zeizel and the Claimed Command Voice 21:34 Emily Thorndike Enters the Courtroom 23:13 The Chaplain and the Persistent Male Voice 27:10 Dr. Phillip Resnick and Filicide 32:42 The Prosecution Rebuttal Begins 38:02 Intrusive Thoughts Versus Hallucinations 41:42 The Residue That Wasn't Confirmed 44:32 Religion, the Mistrial Request and Bowden 48:01 Defense and Prosecution Closing Arguments 55:00 Our Biggest Questions and Jury Predictions